You are currently viewing Can I Use A Harness Instead Of A Collar For Walking My Dog?

Can I Use A Harness Instead Of A Collar For Walking My Dog?

If you’ve ever wondered whether a harness would be a better option than a collar for walking your furry companion, you’re not alone. The debate over which is the best choice for your dog’s comfort and safety while out on walks has been ongoing for quite some time. In this article, we’ll examine the benefits of using a harness for walking your dog and delve into why it might be a suitable alternative to a traditional collar. So, if you’re ready to hit the pavement with your four-legged friend and want to make the best decision for their comfort and well-being, read on to find out if a harness could be the right option for you.

Benefits of Using a Harness

Even Distribution of Pressure

Using a harness for walking your dog provides the benefit of evenly distributing pressure across their body, as opposed to concentrating it on their neck and throat like a collar does. This can greatly reduce the risk of injury or strain, particularly for dogs that tend to pull or lunge while on a leash. By distributing the pressure, a harness can make the walking experience more comfortable and enjoyable for both you and your furry friend.

Reduced Strain on Neck and Throat

Collars can put significant strain on a dog’s neck and throat, especially if they tend to pull or explore avidly during walks. This strain can lead to discomfort, choking, and even potential damage to the trachea. In contrast, a harness disperses the force throughout the chest and shoulders, providing a safer alternative for your dog. This is particularly important for breeds with delicate neck structures, such as small dogs or those prone to respiratory issues.

Better Control and Handling

One of the key advantages of using a harness is the improved control and handling it offers. Harnesses are designed to give you better leverage and control, making it easier to guide and redirect your dog’s movements. Whether you have a strong or energetic dog, or one that tends to get easily distracted, a harness can give you the added support and control you need to ensure a safe and enjoyable walking experience.

Prevents Escaping or Backing Out

Dogs with a knack for slipping out of collars or reversing out of them can create a safety hazard during walks. Harnesses provide a secure fit around the dog’s body, making it nearly impossible for them to escape or back out of the harness. This is especially beneficial for dogs who are fearful or anxious, as the added security can help prevent them from bolting or running away when faced with stressful situations.

Types of Harnesses

Back-Clip Harness

A back-clip harness is a popular choice for most dogs, as it is designed with a clip or D-ring positioned on the back of the harness. This allows the leash to be attached on the dog’s back, near the shoulder blades. Back-clip harnesses are versatile and easy to use, making them a great option for everyday walks, and they distribute pressure evenly across the dog’s body.

Front-Clip Harness

A front-clip harness, as the name suggests, has the leash attachment located at the front of the dog’s chest. This design helps to discourage pulling behavior by redirecting your dog’s forward motion when they pull on the leash. Front-clip harnesses are particularly helpful for dogs in the training phase, as they provide extra control and discourage leash pulling.

Dual-Clip Harness

A dual-clip harness combines the benefits of both a front-clip and back-clip harness, as it features leash attachment points on both the front and back. This provides you with the flexibility to choose the attachment point that best suits your walking needs. For instance, using the front attachment can help with training and discouraging pulling, while the back attachment can be convenient for casual walks or if your dog is already well-behaved on a leash.

Can I Use A Harness Instead Of A Collar For Walking My Dog?

Considerations When Choosing a Harness

Breeds and Body Shape

Different dog breeds and body shapes may require specific types of harnesses. For example, dogs with deep chests, such as Greyhounds or Whippets, may benefit from a harness designed to accommodate their body shape. On the other hand, smaller dogs or those with respiratory issues may require a lightweight and breathable harness. Considering your dog’s breed and body shape when choosing a harness ensures the best fit and comfort.

Existing Medical Conditions

If your dog has any pre-existing medical conditions, it is essential to consult with your veterinarian before selecting a harness. Certain conditions, like arthritis or spinal issues, may require a harness with additional support or specific features to prevent further discomfort or injury. Your veterinarian can provide guidance on the most suitable harness for your dog’s specific needs.

Training Goals

The goals you have for your dog’s training can also influence your choice of harness. If leash pulling is a concern, a front-clip harness may be beneficial, as it helps redirect their attention and discourages pulling. Alternatively, if you are focused on loose-leash walking or off-leash training, a back-clip harness may be more appropriate. Understanding your training goals will help you select a harness that aligns with your desired outcomes.

Behavioral Issues

If your dog has behavioral issues, such as aggression or fearfulness, selecting the right harness can play a crucial role in managing their behavior during walks. A well-fitting and secure harness can provide you with better control and help create a sense of security for your dog. It is advisable to seek guidance from a professional dog trainer or animal behaviorist to ensure you choose a harness that supports your efforts in addressing their specific behavioral challenges.

Training Your Dog to Use a Harness

Introducing the Harness

Introducing your dog to a harness should be a positive and gradual process to ensure they associate it with pleasant experiences. Start by letting your dog sniff and investigate the harness before attempting to put it on. Use treats and praise to create a positive association with the harness. Once your dog is comfortable with the harness, carefully and gently guide their limbs through the designated openings. Make sure to fasten the harness securely but not too tightly.

Positive Reinforcement Techniques

Positive reinforcement is a highly effective training method for getting your dog to accept and enjoy wearing a harness. Reward your dog with treats, praise, and affection whenever they show progress in accepting and wearing the harness. Gradually increase the amount of time your dog spends wearing the harness, gradually building up to longer walks. By associating the harness with positive experiences, your dog will become more enthusiastic about using it.

Gradual Transition from Collar

If your dog is accustomed to wearing a collar, it is recommended to transition them slowly to wearing a harness. Begin by attaching a leash to both the collar and the harness, allowing your dog to feel the sensation of both simultaneously. As your dog becomes comfortable with the harness, gradually reduce their reliance on the collar until they are solely using the harness for walks. This gradual transition will help your dog adjust and make the switch more smoothly.

Consistency and Patience

Training your dog to use a harness requires consistency and patience. Establish a routine and incorporate regular training sessions to reinforce positive behavior. Practice putting on and taking off the harness without going for a walk to desensitize your dog to the process. Be patient if your dog initially resists or feels uncomfortable wearing the harness. With time, patience, and positive reinforcement, most dogs can learn to love wearing their harness.

Can I Use A Harness Instead Of A Collar For Walking My Dog?

Common Myths about Harnesses

Restricts Natural Movement

One common myth about harnesses is that they restrict a dog’s natural movement. However, when properly fitted, harnesses do not hinder your dog’s mobility. In fact, they ensure more controlled and comfortable movement, as the pressure is distributed evenly across their body. It allows your dog to move freely while providing the necessary control for safe and enjoyable walks.

Encourages Pulling Behavior

Another prevalent myth is that using a harness encourages pulling behavior. While it is true that some dogs may display increased pulling when first introduced to a harness, this behavior can be addressed through proper training and leash management techniques. The front-clip harness, in particular, helps discourage pulling by redirecting your dog’s forward motion when they pull on the leash. When used in conjunction with positive reinforcement and training, a harness can actually help reduce pulling behavior over time.

Only for Large or Strong Dogs

Contrary to popular belief, harnesses are not exclusively designed for large or strong dogs. Dogs of all sizes and strengths can benefit from a harness. Small dogs, in particular, may benefit from using a harness to prevent strain on their delicate necks and throats. Harnesses come in a variety of sizes and styles, making it easy to find one that is suitable for your dog, regardless of their size or strength.

Preventing Chafing or Discomfort

Proper Fit and Adjustment

To prevent chafing or discomfort, it is crucial to ensure that the harness fits your dog properly. Measure your dog’s chest and neck circumference to select the appropriate size. When adjusting the harness, ensure that there is enough room for a few fingers to fit comfortably between the harness and your dog’s body. Avoid making the harness too tight or too loose, as both can cause discomfort and potential chafing.

Choosing the Right Material

The material of the harness is also important in preventing chafing or discomfort. Look for harnesses made from soft, breathable, and durable materials that won’t irritate your dog’s skin. Avoid materials that may cause excessive rubbing or friction, such as rough fabrics or those with stiff edges. It is also worth considering a harness with padded sections, especially in areas that may come into direct contact with your dog’s skin.

Regular Inspection

Regularly inspect your dog’s harness for any signs of wear and tear, loose stitching, or frayed straps. Over time, harnesses may become damaged or lose their effectiveness, potentially leading to discomfort or safety issues. Replace the harness if you notice any significant signs of wear or if it no longer fits properly. Regular inspections ensure that your dog’s harness remains in optimal condition and continues to provide comfort and security.

Using Padding or Liners

Using padding or liners within the harness can provide additional comfort and help prevent chafing. These accessories can be particularly beneficial for dogs with sensitive skin or those prone to irritation. Look for soft, breathable padding that can be easily attached or removed from the harness. Be sure to regularly clean and inspect the padding or liners to maintain cleanliness and prevent any potential build-up of bacteria.

Can I Use A Harness Instead Of A Collar For Walking My Dog?

Special Considerations for Puppies

Gentle and Gradual Introduction

When introducing a harness to a puppy, it is crucial to go slowly and gently. Puppies are still developing physically and may find wearing a harness unfamiliar or uncomfortable at first. Begin by allowing them to sniff and interact with the harness before attempting to put it on. Use positive reinforcement techniques, treats, and plenty of praise to create positive associations with the harness.

Choosing Lightweight and Adjustable Harnesses

Puppies grow quickly, so it is essential to choose a lightweight and adjustable harness that can accommodate their changing size. Avoid harnesses that are too restrictive or have fixed sizes. Opt for a harness that allows for easy adjustments as your puppy grows, ensuring a comfortable and secure fit at all stages of their development.

Avoiding Excessive Strain on Growing Bodies

Puppies’ bodies are still developing, and excessive strain or pressure can potentially cause musculoskeletal issues. Make sure to choose a harness that supports your puppy’s body appropriately without putting undue strain on their developing bones and joints. Avoid excessive pulling or jerking on the leash during walks to minimize any potential risks to their growing body.

Using a Collar and Harness Together

Attaching Leashes to Both

Using a collar and harness together can provide additional security and control during walks. By attaching the leash to both the collar and the harness, you have a backup option in case one fails or comes loose. This double attachment system can give you peace of mind, especially if your dog tends to be a skilled escape artist or if you are walking in an unfamiliar or crowded area.

Benefits of Dual Usage

The combination of a collar and a harness can offer several benefits. A collar can hold identification tags and provide quick access to your dog’s information in case they become lost. The harness, on the other hand, provides better control, minimizes strain on the neck, and reduces the risk of injury. The dual usage allows for a flexible and adaptable approach, catering to your dog’s individual needs and providing added safety measures.

Can I Use A Harness Instead Of A Collar For Walking My Dog?

Additional Equipment for Walking Dogs


A leash is an essential piece of equipment for walking your dog. Choose a leash that is comfortable to hold and appropriate for your dog’s size and strength. Consider the length of the leash depending on the walking environment and your dog’s training level. Retractable leashes can offer more freedom for certain situations but may not be suitable for all dogs, particularly those prone to pulling or behavioral issues.

Collapsible Water Bowls

When taking your dog for a walk, especially in warmer weather, it is important to keep them hydrated. Collapsible water bowls are a convenient and portable accessory that allows you to offer your dog water during breaks or longer walks. These bowls are lightweight and can be easily carried in a bag or attached to a leash, ensuring your dog has access to fresh water whenever needed.

Treat Pouches

A treat pouch is a handy accessory for training or rewarding good behavior during walks. It provides a convenient and easily accessible storage solution for treats, allowing you to reinforce positive behavior promptly. Look for a treat pouch that is easy to clean and has enough space for an adequate supply of treats. Some pouches also come with additional pockets to hold other essentials, such as poop bags or keys.

Poop Bags

Responsible dog ownership includes proper waste disposal. Carrying poop bags during walks ensures that you can pick up after your dog and maintain a clean and tidy environment. There are various options available, from biodegradable bags to scented options that mask odors. Choose the type of poop bags that align with your preferences and environmental values.

Professional Opinions and Expert Recommendations


Veterinarians generally recommend the use of harnesses over collars, especially for dogs with certain health conditions or behavioral issues. They can provide valuable insights into your dog’s specific needs and advise on the most suitable harness for their individual circumstances. Regular check-ups with your veterinarian can help assess your dog’s overall health and make any necessary adjustments to their walking equipment.

Dog Trainers

Dog trainers often advocate for the use of harnesses as a training tool. They can offer guidance on selecting a harness that best suits your training goals and provide expert advice on proper leash management techniques. Engaging a dog trainer can help address any behavioral issues related to walking, such as pulling or leash-reactivity, and ensure a positive and effective training experience.

Animal Behaviorists

Animal behaviorists specialize in understanding and modifying animal behavior. They can provide valuable insights into the emotional and psychological factors that may influence your dog’s behavior during walks. Consulting with an animal behaviorist can be particularly helpful if your dog exhibits significant fear, anxiety, or aggression during walks, as they can provide strategies and recommend the most appropriate walking equipment, such as harnesses, to help manage these issues effectively.

In conclusion, using a harness instead of a collar has numerous benefits for walking your dog. It promotes an even distribution of pressure, reduces strain on the neck and throat, offers better control and handling, and prevents escaping or backing out. When choosing a harness, consider your dog’s breed, body shape, existing medical conditions, training goals, and any behavioral issues they may have. Proper training techniques, debunking common myths about harnesses, preventing chafing or discomfort, and considering special considerations for puppies are all essential aspects to ensure a successful transition to using a harness. Using a collar and harness together can provide added security, while additional equipment like leashes, collapsible water bowls, treat pouches, and poop bags enhance the overall walking experience. Seeking professional opinions and expert recommendations from veterinarians, dog trainers, and animal behaviorists can further guide you in selecting the right harness and ensuring that your dog’s walking routine is safe, enjoyable, and beneficial for their overall well-being.

Can I Use A Harness Instead Of A Collar For Walking My Dog?

Related Posts

Leave a Reply